Doctors for Patients UK All articles
Patient-Doctor Relationships

The Right to Refuse: Consent, Capacity and Saying No to NHS Treatment

Doctors for Patients UK
The Right to Refuse: Consent, Capacity and Saying No to NHS Treatment

Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

There is a moment, familiar to almost every patient, when a clinician proposes a course of action and the conversation moves swiftly towards agreement. Papers are produced. A date is set. The patient, who may have reservations they have not quite formulated, finds the moment for objection has passed almost before it arrived.

This is not because patients lack the right to refuse. Legally and ethically, the position is unambiguous: a competent adult may decline any medical treatment, for any reason or none, and that refusal must be respected. What patients frequently lack is not the right but the vocabulary, the confidence and the knowledge of how to exercise it in a way that is understood and documented.

Consent is a process, not a signature

A consent form is evidence that a discussion took place. It is not the discussion itself, and signing one does not extinguish your right to change your mind. Consent must be given voluntarily, by someone with the capacity to make the particular decision in question, and on the basis of sufficient information. It can be withdrawn at any point, including after treatment has begun.

This matters because the pressure of a hospital ward — the early morning visit from a surgeon, the consent form already printed, the theatre list already scheduled — can make a request for time feel unreasonable. It is not. Asking to think about a decision overnight is an ordinary exercise of autonomy, not an obstruction.

What "informed" actually requires

The legal standard changed materially with the Supreme Court's judgment in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board in 2015. The question is no longer what a reasonable doctor would have disclosed, but what a reasonable patient in your position would want to know. That includes material risks, however small the probability, if the consequences would be significant to you; the alternatives available; and the consequences of declining treatment altogether.

In practical terms, you are entitled to ask: what are the risks, and how likely are they? What are the benefits, and how likely are they? What happens if I do nothing? What alternatives exist, including less invasive ones? Who will perform the procedure, and how often have they done it?

If those questions cannot be answered in the appointment available, ask for a further conversation. A clinician who cannot explain a risk to your satisfaction has not yet obtained valid consent.

Capacity: the presumption that protects you

The Mental Capacity Act 2005, which applies in England and Wales, begins from a presumption of capacity. A person is not to be treated as unable to make a decision merely because they make an unwise one. Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific: you may lack capacity to manage complex financial affairs while retaining full capacity to decide about a hip replacement.

Assessment involves two questions. Does the person have an impairment of, or a disturbance in the functioning of, the mind or brain? If so, can they understand the relevant information, retain it, weigh it and communicate a decision? A refusal that clinicians find surprising or inconvenient does not, by itself, indicate incapacity. Scotland and Northern Ireland operate under their own statutory frameworks, but the same principles of presumption and specificity apply.

Refusing one treatment is not refusing all care

Patients often worry that declining a recommended intervention will be read as disengagement, with the result that other support quietly falls away. It should not be. You may decline a particular operation while still accepting physiotherapy, pain management, monitoring or follow-up. Being explicit about what you are accepting, alongside what you are declining, keeps the therapeutic relationship intact and makes the record clearer.

Advance decisions and emergency care planning

An advance decision to refuse treatment (sometimes called a living will) can be legally binding if it is valid and applicable to the circumstances, and if it refuses specific treatments rather than expressing general wishes. Refusals of life-sustaining treatment must be in writing, signed and witnessed. In Scotland, the equivalent mechanism is an advance directive, which does not carry the same statutory force but must be taken into account.

Emergency care planning documents — such as a ReSPECT form — record agreed recommendations about treatment in a future crisis. These are not refusals in themselves; they are a record of a conversation. If you have strong views about what you would and would not want, having that conversation in advance is far more effective than hoping it will be inferred.

Leaving hospital against advice

A patient with capacity may leave hospital at any time, even when clinicians strongly advise against it. Staff may ask you to sign a form recording that you are leaving against medical advice and may explain the risks; they cannot lawfully detain you. If you are considering this, ask for three things: a written summary of the risks discussed, any medication you need, and details of follow-up or who to contact if your condition deteriorates. Requesting these turns an abrupt departure into a managed one.

When others are involved

For children and young people, competence is assessed individually rather than by age alone. Where an adult lacks capacity, decisions are made in their best interests, and a registered lasting power of attorney for health and welfare — or, in Scotland, a welfare attorney — may have authority to decide. An independent mental capacity advocate can be appointed in certain situations.

Making your decision heard

  1. State the decision plainly. "I am declining the operation at this stage" is clearer than a string of hesitations.
  2. Give your reasons if you wish, but do not feel obliged to justify them. A refusal does not require a persuasive rationale.
  3. Ask for the discussion to be recorded in your notes, including what you were told about risks.
  4. Ask what happens next. A good service will explain how you will be monitored and how to re-engage if you change your mind.
  5. Request a second opinion if you feel the decision is being handled dismissively rather than discussed.

If you feel pressured

Persuasion is part of clinical care; coercion is not. If you feel that a decision is being rushed, that your questions are being deflected, or that your refusal is being treated as irrational, you are entitled to ask for the conversation to be paused and for a senior clinician to be involved. Patient advice and liaison services, and independent advocacy organisations, can support you in raising it.

The right to say no is not an adversarial right. It is the mechanism by which medicine remains a partnership rather than something done to people. Exercised clearly and recorded properly, it protects the patient and, in the end, the clinician too.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Second Pair of Ears: Turning a Loved One Into Your Most Effective Medical Ally

The Second Pair of Ears: Turning a Loved One Into Your Most Effective Medical Ally

When Nobody Knows Your Full Story: The Hidden Danger of Fragmented GP Care and How to Protect Yourself

When Nobody Knows Your Full Story: The Hidden Danger of Fragmented GP Care and How to Protect Yourself

The Hidden Half of Your Medicine Cabinet: What Your GP Doesn't Know Could Hurt You

The Hidden Half of Your Medicine Cabinet: What Your GP Doesn't Know Could Hurt You